Company Loyalty: Career Starter or Career Staller?

It’s become a common refrain to criticize young professionals’ tendency to job hop practically every other year, so much so that millennials have developed a negative reputation for it. Their willingness to frequently change jobs can convey disengagement at work and a lack of loyalty to their organizations, which employers may view as a serious red flag.

But does the opposite situation raise a red flag? When a prospective employee has been at the same job for 10 or 15 years, what message does that send to employers? In this age of professional mobility and regular job hopping, it’s important to demonstrate growth and progression if you’ve spent a significant amount of time at one organization.

Working at the same company for 15 years can be great—working in the same role for 15 years could be a problem. It’s vital to frame the situation to show development, otherwise what one manager sees as loyalty and stability could easily be viewed as a lack of motivation and stagnation by another. For anyone job searching after a significant amount of time at their current company, reflecting on how their role and responsibilities have evolved through the years is a crucial first step before going into an interview. Think about promotions and increased responsibilities and try to quantify how your role has broadened with the organization’s own growth. For example, how many dollars, people, or projects were you responsible for when you first started, at the midpoint of your career, and in your current position? Being unable to identify these things over a long span of time might raise some questions on the part of a prospective employer: Why haven’t you been given—or looked for—more responsibility? Are you satisfied with your job or do you feel stagnant?

An employee’s professional goal is to travel a two-way street with their company. Employees want to learn and develop skills (what the organization gives them) and contribute a lot (the value they add to the organization). Part of millennials’ “bad” reputation is because they are seen as taking advantage of the development opportunities but not always contributing proportionately. The employer/employee dynamic should be a positive, mutually rewarding relationship. An employee shouldn’t expect to learn a lot, be trained, and then move on before giving back to the organization. But the opposite situation is detrimental, too—being in the same job for 15 years might mean you’re learning less and not adding to the contributions you make.

Will this be cause for concern in a job search? As is so often the case, it depends. There may be great reasons for staying in the same position for an extended period of time that have nothing to do with being complacent or unmotivated. For example, an illness, caring for young children or elderly parents, or getting an advanced degree would be excellent reasons for staying in the same role. As long as you can ultimately show that you developed and excelled at a skill and were adding value—in the job, at home, or through another personal passion—you can shed a positive light on the situation. Ensure you can demonstrate your desire for further professional growth, which has led you to seek a new opportunity, so that this potential employer won’t find it difficult to understand your career motivations.

So, are the job-hopping millennials on to something? Should everyone change jobs regularly? Balance is key. Demonstrate your position on that two-way street—what you’ve learned, how you’ve challenged yourself, and what value you’ve provided. Growth and organizational loyalty do not have to be mutually exclusive: It’s possible to develop professionally while also showing commitment to just one organization.


Add Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

How Jim Thome Shifted from MLB Slugger to Business
Mike Petters Huntington Ingalls
10 Things You Didn’t Know about Huntington Ingalls CEO Mike Petters
seth goldman honest tea
10 Things You Didn’t Know about Honest Tea’s Seth Goldman
How Erin Burnett Achieved a Net Worth of $13 Million
chase sapphire reserve card
How to Get The Most out of Chase Sapphire Reserve Concierge
interest Rates
Understanding the Interest Rates Phenomenon
Why Microsoft (MSFT) is a Safe Dividend Stock for the Next 20 Years
chase sapphire reserve card
Whatever Happened to The Chase Sapphire Reserve Price Protection Plan?
Productivity 101: Why you Should Consider a Time Tracking Tool
Biosphere 2
Closed Ecological Systems: Can They Save the Future?
brain computer interface
How Close is Brain-Computer Interface To Being a Reality?
agricultural robots
What Are Agricultural Robots and How Will They Change the Future?
10 Reasons to Stay at the Ritz Carlton NYC, Central Park
american cut nyc
Why American Cut is One of NYC’s Best Steakhouses
New York Earth Room
10 Reasons to Visit the New York Earth Room
High Line
10 Reasons You Should Walk the NYC High Line
1954 Ferrari 375-Plus
A Closer Look at the $18.3 Million 1954 Ferrari 375-Plus
1964 Ferrari 250 LM Rear
Is the 1964 Ferrari 250 LM Really Worth $18.26 Million?
1966 Shelby GT350
The 20 Greatest Muscle Cars of All-Time
1956 Cadillac Series 62 Eldorado Seville Coupe
The 20 Best Cadillac Eldorado Models of All Time
A Closer Look at the $3.6 Patek Philippe 1928 Single Button Chronograph
Patek Philippe Pink Gold Pocket Watch 1894
A Closer Look at the $2.29 Million Patek Philippe Pink Gold Pocket Watch 1894
Patek Philippe Perpetual Calendar Chronograph Wristwatch in Pink Gold
A Closer Look at the $2.28 Million Patek Philippe Perpetual Calendar Chronograph Wristwatch in Pink Gold
20 Things That You Didn’t Know About Breitling Watches