Why MMT is Nothing More than Another Ponzi Scheme

Money

A recent story in The Wall Street Journal discussed the new economic theory on the block known as Modern Monetary Theory (MMT).  This is a concept that was developed over time, but its birth as a “theory” came around 1947 in an article written by economist Abba Lerner.  It is an extension of an older concept known as Chartalism, which was developed by German economist, Georg Friedrich Knapp, as an argument against the gold standard.  Knapp argued that governments could create paper money and recognize it as legal tender, and that money could serve as a means of exchange in the same way as gold.

The MMT goes much further, in suggesting that states can create an unlimited amount of paper money as long as there is enough slack in the economy to keep the growth in currency from being inflationary.  Deficits do not matter, and the economy is only constrained by the specter of inflation. The popularity of the theory among political elites is obvious in that it gives them a blank check to spend.

Like most economic theories, MMT does make many good points.  There is much merit to the argument that governments cannot effectively control the economy by tinkering with interest rates, so too is the idea that fiscal policy is much more useful than monetary policy at actually guiding growth.  However, suggesting that governments have a free lunch and can have the economy follow their bidding simply by printing money is patently absurd.

In fact, MMT is based on the false presumption that money is inherently valuable. This is simply not true, as even commodity-based money, in and of itself has no value at all.  Money is effectively no different than a check – you know those old fangled things that we all used to write – acknowledging the payment of a debt.  It’s a means of transaction and a representation of value, but not valuable itself.

The first purpose of money is to facilitate exchange.  If money did not exist, transactions would have to involve barter.  If I want a shirt but I only have a pig to pay for it, the transaction with the tailor becomes difficult.  However, if I can represent the value of the pig using a generally accepted token, be it a shell, a gold coin or a Federal Reserve Note, and the tailor can do the same with the shirt, then we only need to trade tokens, not physical commodities.

The second purpose of money is as a representation of value – in effect a unit of measurement much like an inch, a pound or a gallon.  Again, it is difficult to store, save, and often times use, physical commodities or the results of physical labor.  I can pick hundreds of pecks of apples over the course of a week, but I can’t eat them all or even trade them all for the goods that I need to last the remainder of the year.  I can, however, trade them to a fruit wholesaler for a certain measure of money.  That money represents my week’s work, and can be easily stored in a mattress, a bank or traded for other goods and services over time.

Unless money has value in and of itself, then the ideas of MMT simply can’t hold water.  It is true that the supply of money in an economy can and should grow along with the amount of value created.  If it didn’t then there would be downward pressure of prices.  On the other hand, if the amount of money in the system grows faster than the value produced, there would be upward pressure on prices.  Neither is good, as they would in effect change the measurements represented by money.  How could a building be built when the length of a meter changes every day, or milk be bottled when the volume of a gallon goes up and down with the wind.  Neither can work, and neither can the economy when money no longer serves as a reliable unit of measurement.  Examples abound.  Imperial Rome fell in part due to a debasement of its money, so too did Weimar Germany, and more recently Zimbabwe, Argentina and Venezuela.  Just by looking at the news we can all see that simply printing Bolivars has not done much to grow the Venezuelan economy, and printing dollars will not create wealth in the United States.

Economic theories can be powerful tools to help guide business, consumers, investors and government.  Unfortunately, the public will always be susceptible to the siren song of charlatans selling snake oil, and a free lunch.  MMT is nothing more than another Ponzi scheme posing as a solution to today’s woes.  Let’s not fall for it.

John Dunham is President of John Dunham & Associates. John Dunham & Associates, based in Brooklyn, has built its reputation as a leader in the field of tax and regulatory economics by producing economic impact studies that are clear, concise, and effective. They can be a great source for any of your stories needing economic analysis.

Add Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Careers CEOs Companies Education Entertainment Legal Politics Science Sports Technology
plane
20 Things You Didn’t Know about Reliable Robotics
Vikram Chopra
10 Things You Didn’t Know about Vikram Chopra
writing
20 Things You Didn’t Know about Quillbot
Collectibles Credit Cards Investing Real Estate Stocks
BFT Stock
Is BFT Stock a Solid Long-Term Investment?
eBay
How to Retract an Offer on Ebay
Texas
20 Weird Laws in Texas That Actually Still Exist
Aviation Boats Food & Drink Hotels Restaurants Yachts
Project Sonata
A Closer Look at the 351-Foot Sailing Yacht “Project Sonata”
Florida State Parks
The 10 Best State Parks to Visit in Florida
Folly Beach
The 20 Best Beaches to Visit in South Carolina
BMW Bugatti Cadillac Ferrari Lamborghini Mercedes Porsche Rolls Royce
2022 Lucid Air Dream Edition
A Closer Look at The 2022 Lucid Air Dream Edition
2022 Porsche 911 GTS
A Closer Look at The 2022 Porsche 911 GTS
TVR T440R Sports Car
A Closer Look at the Only TVR T440R Sports Car in the World
BMW Motorcycles Buell Ducati Harley Davidson Honda Motorcycles Husqvarna Kawasaki KTM Triumph Motorcycles Yamaha
Triumph Tiger Motorcycles
The Five Best Triumph Tiger Motorcycles Money Can Buy
MV Agusta Brutale 1000 Nürburgring
A Closer Look at the MV Agusta Brutale 1000 Nürburgring
2011 Harley-Davidson Sportster SuperLow
Remembering The 2011 Harley-Davidson Sportster SuperLow
Electronics Fashion Health Home Jewelry Pens Sneakers Watches
Reading Chairs
The 10 Best Reading Chairs to Relax In
Zenith El Primero
The 10 Best Two Tone Watches Money Can Buy
Chore Coat
The 10 Best Chore Coats Money Can Buy
Charles Stanley
How Charles Stanley Achieved a Net Worth of $1.5 Million
David Copperfield
How David Copperfield Achieved a Net Worth of $1 Billion
Tim McGraw and Faith Hill
How Faith Hill Achieved a Net Worth of $165 Million
Fauci
How Dr. Fauci Achieved a Net Worth of $2.5 Million