St. Augustine’s is a port town in Florida, so it is hardly surprising that fish and seafood feature strongly on the menus in the area as there is an excellent fresh supply of these ingredients. Many of the restaurants specialize in serving fish and seafood dishes, and there are some outstanding eateries to choose between. While some are perfect for a casual lunch, others are fine dining options that are better suited to special occasions. Each has something different to offer that makes it stand out from the competition, so you may have some difficulty choosing the best eatery for you. The following are the 10 best seafood restaurants in St. Augustine, Florida.
10. Hurricane Patty’s
If you want to enjoy seafood dishes inspired by international cuisines and flavors, then Hurricane Patty’s is a good option. Expect to find on the menu everything from Caribbean fish dishes to Moroccan chowder. There is also a raw bar featuring a vast array of fresh seafood. Another reason to visit this restaurant is to try one of the many rum drinks on offer.
9. Harry’s Seafood Bar & Grill
Southern and Creole-style fare are the main offerings from Harry’s Seafood Bar & Grill, which is a Florida-based mini-chain. Typical examples of dishes include po’boys and jambalaya. Open for both lunch and dinner, diners have the option of eating either inside the restaurant or outside on the courtyard. The restaurant is housed in one of the oldest bayfront homes in the town. It is a fantastic place to eat with friends as you can hang out with a drink to listen to live music under the outdoor canopy most evenings.
8. Michael’s Tasting Room
Michaels Tasting Room has become known for its exquisite Mediterranean tapas, which is in keeping with the Spanish style of the building that houses this restaurant. However, there is plenty more on offer on the diverse and seasonally changing menu. Although seafood dishes inspired by the cuisine of the Iberian Peninsula are the highlight of a meal at this establishment, there are also meat and vegetarian dishes available. Michael’s Tasting Room also has an award-winning wine list for you to accompany your meal with a wine that compliments the flavors.
7. O’Steen’s Restaurant
O’Steen’s Restaurant is a well-established business as it has been serving seafood to locals for more than half a century. Located on Anastasia Island, this is a laid-back restaurant that is ideal for casual dining. The dishes are made using mostly locally sourced seafood, although many of the dishes have a Mediterranean twist. As this restaurant is so popular and it is only small, you can expect to wait for a table if you haven’t booked in advance. It is also worth noting that this is a cash-only restaurant, so don’t forget to take your wallet.
6. Llama Restaurant
A fairly new venue that has quickly become a favorite among the locals is Llama Restaurant. This New Peruvian restaurant has only been open since 2016, and it is located on Anastasia Island. The décor of the restaurant is visually appealing, and the friendly customer service has been praised. Now, it is considered one of the hottest places to eat in town. Although this is predominantly a seafood restaurant and the ceviche has been described as a work of art, there are also meat and vegetarian options on the menu. Therefore, there is something for everyone in your dining party, regardless of whether they are all seafood enthusiasts or not.
5. Catch 27
Bay Front Marin House recommends Catch 27, which is a seafood restaurant located on Charlotte Street. This restaurant moved to this location in 2016 after originally being positioned just a few blocks away. Although it is only a small restaurant, there is also an outdoor eating area. The menu features fresh, local ingredients, and a catch of the day is featured daily.
4. Collage Restaurant
At Collage Restaurant, internationally-inspired dishes are created using the best local ingredients. Some examples of dishes on the menu include a crusted grouper, lobster ravioli with a pesto cream sauce, and sautéed escargots in puff pastry. This quaint restaurant is located in the historic district of St. Augustine’s, and it is considered one of the top venues to enjoy a romantic meal.
Even before stepping into this restaurant you can tell that you are in for a treat as Preserved is housed in an 1865 Lincolnville Victorian house. The interior space is equally as impressive, and the food on offer is some of the best in the area. On the menu, you will find traditional seafood dishes that have been given a modern twist by James Beard nominee chef Brian Whittington. Many of the dishes are influenced by southern American cuisine. This establishment is part of the Strive Restaurant Group.
2. The Floridian
The cuisine in northern Florida includes many dishes that are inspired by southern fare, and it is this style of dishes that you will find on the menu. Inside the restaurant, there is light and bright décor that gives it a cool, tropical vibe. Although this is a seafood restaurant, there are plenty of options on the menu for vegetarians and vegans, including an interesting range of tofu dishes.
1. Ice Plant
According to Time Out, the best seafood restaurant in St. Augustine’s, Florida, is Ice Plant. This restaurant is in a 1920s ice factory that has been restored to create a stunning restaurant and bar. The dishes on the menu focus on Floridian cuisine that is made using fresh, locally sourced ingredients. It is not only the food that has made this a noteworthy venue, as it is also known for its drinks, which are also inspired by Florida and feature huge chunks of ice hacked off enormous ice blocks.