The 10 Best Seafood Restaurants in Siesta Key

The Cottage

Like all locations on Florida’s coast, Siesta Key is a fantastic place to dine out if you are a seafood enthusiast. There is a multitude of amazing seafood restaurants that take advantage of the delicious ingredients that are available from the waters surrounding this state. If you are dining out in Siesta Key, you will find seafood restaurants to suit all tastes and budgets, with eateries that serve a vast array of cuisines in some stunning settings. To help you decide where to eat, the following are the 10 best seafood restaurants in Siesta Key, Florida.

Ophelia's on the Bay

10. Ophelia’s on the Bay

If you are celebrating a special occasion or you want to enjoy a romantic meal, then one of the best seafood restaurants in Siesta Key is Ophelia’s on the Beach. This fine dining establishment is an award-winning, upscale restaurant on Midnight Pass Road that has an excellent reputation in the local area. It is an elegant restaurant that boasts floor-to-ceiling so that diners can enjoy views across the bay. There is also a bayside patio for those who prefer alfresco dining. The seafood-centric menu changes daily to take advantage of the availability of locally-sourced and seasonal ingredients. Although it is a fine dining establishment, it is accessible for those on a budget as it has a daily happy hour.

Cafe Gabbiano

9. Café Gabbiano

Those who enjoy both seafood and Italian cuisine should consider booking a table at Café Gabbiano. This Italian restaurant features a wide selection of seafood options on its menu that use locally-caught fish and seafood. There is a choice of dining options at this restaurant, including the main dining room, private dining rooms, wine rooms, and outdoor seating on a climate-controlled patio. Café Gabbiano is located on Ocean Boulevard and it is open from 5 pm to 10 pm daily.

The Old Salty Dog

8. The Old Salty Dog

Open since 1986, The Old Salty Dog is a well-established restaurant in Siesta Key. The owners aimed to combine the feel of a traditional British pub with the style of the Florida Keys to create a casual village seafood restaurant and pub. One of the most popular items on the menu is the traditional British fish and chips. The Siesta Key location of The Old Salty Dog is on Ocean Boulevard. There are two more locations in City Island and Venice Island.

7. Blue Que Island Grill (Closed)

The tropical island atmosphere at this restaurant makes it a popular place to eat. Diners can enjoy a wide selection of both seafood and meat dishes, including hardwood hickory-smoked meats and fish, crab soup, and lobster bisque. It is a low-key bistro-style restaurant that offers a wide selection of craft beers. Diners have the option to dine alfresco on the spacious patio. You will find this restaurant on Avenida Messina.

Daiquiri Deck

6. Daiquiri Deck

It is the raw bar that makes Daquiri Deck on Ocean Boulevard stand out from the competition as it is full of fresh and delicious raw seafood ingredients. There is also a full menu with hot seafood options to enjoy. This restaurant is part of a small, local chain that is known for keeping diners entertained with live performances. It is also known for its impressive menu of frozen drinks. This is one of the best places to eat if you fancy a late-night meal as it is open from 11 am daily and closes at midnight from Sunday to Thursday and at 2 am on Fridays and Saturday.

Captain Curt's

5. Capt. Curt’s Crab and Oyster Bar

Capt. Curt’s Crab and Oyster Bar is the epitome of a traditional Floridian seafood joint. It is famous in the area for its fresh local catch seafood, and also for being a fun venue with music. Some examples from the menu include clam chowder, oyster, grouper fillets, and sandwiches. There is the option to dine outside at the tiki bar to take advantage of the warm weather. This eatery was named as the best family restaurant in Siesta Keys by the Travel Channel.

The Cottage

4. The Cottage Restaurant

The Culture Trip lists The Cottage Restaurant as one of the top seafood restaurants in Siesta Key. This bistro is praised for its farm-to-table approach to cooking, and for its fusion culinary style. The menu consists predominantly of seafood dishes, which are made using the freshest ingredients. There is also an extensive wine list and a good selection of craft beers.

Siesta Key Oyster Bar

3. Siesta Key Oyster Bar

One of the best venues for oyster lovers is the Siesta Key Oyster Bar. The casual seafood menu at this island-style patio bar is award-winning, and the oysters are the highlight of a visit. Alongside the other seafood dishes, there are also wings and burgers on this diverse menu. On a nice day, diners enjoy sitting outside on the deck to enjoy their meal accompanied by a craft beer, of which there is a broad selection.

Lobster Pot

2. The Lobster Pot Restaurant

Those who favor New England-style seafood dishes should head to The Lobster Pot Restaurant. Located in Siesta Key Village, this restaurant specializes in lobster dishes, including lobster bisque, stuffed lobsters, and baked lobsters. However, lobster is not the only option on the menu as there are plenty of other dishes, including clam chowder and a wide selection of baked and fried fish and seafood. You will also find steaks and pasta dishes on the menu.

Turtles on the Bay

1. Turtles on the Bay

According to Visit Siesta Key, the best seafood restaurant in Siesta Key is Turtles on the Bay. Diners can choose from an array of wonderful seafood dishes and dine in a casual tropical environment that boasts breathtaking views of Little Sarasota Bay. In addition to the amazing seafood options, this restaurant also serves steaks. Therefore, there is something for everyone on the menu. Turtles on the Bat has been open since 1986, and it is a favorite spot amongst the locals.



Add Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Balenciaga
The History of and Story Behind the Balenciaga Logo
Robert Smith
10 Things You Didn’t Know about Billionaire Robert Smith
Oracle
The History of and Story Behind The Oracle Logo
Pony Ma
10 Things You Didn’t Know about Pony Ma
ETF
Should You Invest in A Soybean ETF?
ETF
Which Emerging Market ETF is Right For You?
ETF
Five Blue Chip ETF Recommendations You Can’t Go Wrong With
ETF
Which Private Equity ETF Should You Invest In?
Billy Frank Jr. Nisqually National Wildlife Refuge
The 20 Best Things to Do in Olympia, WA for First Timers
Olympia WA
The Traveler’s Guide to Hiking in Olympia, WA
Fish Tale Brewpub
The 10 Best Places to Eat in Olympia, WA
Hiking in Ecuador
The Traveler’s Guide to Hiking in Ecuador
1937 Cadillac Phaeton 5859 2
What You Need to Know about Your Cadillac VIN Decoder
Cadillac Station Wagons
The Five Best Cadillac Station Wagons of All-Time
Why 1957 Was a Significant Year for Cadillac
Cadillac Brougham
Whatever Happened to the Cadillac Brougham?
TAG Heuer
The Five Best Tag Heuer Women’s Watches on the Market
Omega Watch
Tag Heuer vs. Omega: Who is the Better Watch Brand?
TAG Heuer
The Buyer’s Guide to Getting a Vintage Tag Heuer Watch
TAG Heuer
The Top Five Tag Heuer Gold Watches of All-Time
Kenya Moore
How Kenya Moore Achieved a Net Worth of $1 Million
Courtney Love
How Courtney Love Achieved a Net Worth of $100 Million
Jon Taffer
How Jon Taffer Achieved a Net Worth of $14 Million
Anuel AA
How Anuel AA Achieved a Net Worth of $6 Million