MoneyINC Logo
Years of

The 10 Best Seafood Restaurants in Indiana


Seafood is one of America's most popular food choices, whether it's fresh steamed shrimp and crab legs or fried fish fillets and clams. From fresh catches available by the pound to award-winning meals prepared by world-class chefs, Indiana state serves up some of the best seafood in the nation. If you're craving seafood in Indiana, you don't have to look further than these ten top-notch restaurants.

10. Kona Jack's Fish Market & Sushi Bar - Meridian North

Kona Jack's Fish Market & Sushi Bar is a local favorite for fresh seafood in the Indianapolis area. The market offers a wide variety of seafood, including sushi-grade fish, live lobster, and King Crab legs. You can also order cooked seafood to go or enjoy a meal in the cozy restaurant. If you also love aquariums, you will love this place more because the place is filled with aquariums. Their seafood is Hawaiian style, and they also have a sushi bar. According to their website, they have an on-site fish market where you can buy some fresh fish and enjoy live music.

9. Chubby Trout - Elkhart

If you want to experience some of the best seafood that Indiana offers, you need to head on over to Chubby Trout. This restaurant is known for its fantastic trout dishes, but they also offer a wide variety of other seafood options. Another great thing about this restaurant is that they brew their beer so that you can enjoy a nice cold one with your meal. The restaurant also has catering options so if you have a party you can book with them.

8. Noa Noa Wood Grill & Sushi Bar - Warsaw

The next place on our list of the ten best seafood restaurants in Indiana is Noa Noa Wood Grill & Sushi Bar, located in Warsaw. Thanks to its fantastic quality and taste, this restaurant may be considered the best sushi place in Indiana. Serving up delicious tropical theme Japanese cuisine and a fantastic selection of sashimi, nigiri, and other sushi dishes, it's no wonder that Noa Noa Wood Grill & Sushi Bar is so famous. With a large selection of appetizers, salads, soups, and desserts, you'll be able to create the perfect meal for any occasion. The restaurant also has an on-site fish market, so if you want to recreate your favorite sushi dishes at home, you'll be able to pick up the ingredients here.

7. Formosa Seafood Buffet - Castleton, IN

Formosa Seafood Buffet in Castleton, Indiana, is a great place to enjoy a delicious seafood buffet. With over 60 different food items available, this restaurant is well known for its extensive buffet and Chinese cuisine, mainly seafood. The menu includes various kinds of sushi and sashimi, crab legs, crawfish, and a wide selection of cooked seafood items. You can also find a variety of traditional Chinese dishes, such as General Tso's Chicken and Kung Pao shrimp. The restaurant also offers desserts, so if you have a sweet tooth, you'll want to check out Formosa Seafood Buffet.

6. Theo's Steaks & Seafood - Highland

Theo's Steaks & Seafood is a family-owned restaurant serving the community for many years. The menu features fresh, never frozen seafood and steak entrees cooked to order. Theo's also offers a wide variety of wine and beer to complement your meal. It is a place you can find both a casual and fine dining experience. According to their website, they can cater to banquets, so they can be the perfect place to host if you have an event coming up.

5. Mitchell's Fish Market - Carmel

At number five, Mitchell's Fish Market is one of the best seafood restaurants in Indiana. Mitchell's Fish Market is located in Carmel, Indiana, and it is known for its wide variety of delicious seafood. This chain has several locations throughout the Great Lakes region, including Carmel, Indiana. Mitchell's Fish Market is known for its wide variety of seafood, including lobster, scallops, shrimp, etc. The Carmel location is also ideal due to its convenient location and its beautiful outdoor patio.

4. Clarksville Seafood - Clarksville

Family-owned businesses could hardly be more charming than Clarksville Seafood. This small, homey restaurant is located in a historic building and serves up some of the best seafood in Indiana. The menu features fresh, local seafood like catfish, trout, and shrimp. Crab cakes are a house specialty and not to be missed. There's also a great selection of fish and chips, which are always tasty, and daily specials like oysters Rockefeller and stuffed flounder. If you're looking for a casual place to enjoy some fantastic seafood, Clarksville Seafood is your spot.

3. Umi Sushi & Lounge - Crown Point

Umi Sushi & Lounge is a favorite among locals and visitors alike. Offering fresh sushi, seafood, and specialty drinks, the restaurant is the perfect place to go when you're craving seafood. Umi Sushi & Lounge is located in the heart of downtown Crown Point, Indiana. The decor is sleek and modern with a touch of Japanese influence. The menu features a wide variety of sushi, sashimi, nigiri, and seafood entrees. The lunch and dinner menus are almost identical, so you can enjoy the restaurant for whatever meal works best for your schedule.

2. Lighthouse Restaurant - Cedar Lake

Another excellent seafood spot in Indiana can be found at the Lighthouse Restaurant in Cedar Lake. The restaurant is located right on the lake, providing stunning views for guests to enjoy while indulging in their seafood feast. The menu offers a variety of seafood items, such as shrimp, lobster, crab cakes, and more. Each dish is made with fresh, high-quality ingredients, providing a memorable and delicious dining experience.

1. Caplinger’s Fresh Catch Seafood Market and Restaurant - Zionsville

At number one, we have Caplinger's Fresh Catch Seafood Market and Restaurant in Zionsville, Indiana. This seafood spot is a local favorite, known for its fresh fish and delicious seafood. Whether you are in the mood for some crab, lobster, or oysters, Caplinger's has got it all. Caplinger 's is an excellent choice for those looking to grab a quick bite or those in the mood for a delicious seafood meal.


There you have it: the top 10 seafood restaurants in Indiana. If you're looking for a fantastic meal out, check out these great restaurants. Whether you're craving crab, shrimp, or something else entirely, there's a seafood restaurant on this list that will satisfy your cravings. So what are you waiting for? Go out and enjoy some of the best seafood in Indiana.

Liz Flynn

Written by Liz Flynn

Liz Flynn has worked as a full-time writer since 2010 after leaving a career in education. She finds almost all topics she writes about interesting, but her favorite subjects are travel and food. Liz loves the process of researching information, learning new things, and putting into words what others who share her interests might like to read. Although she spends most of her time writing, she also enjoys spending time with her husband and four children, watching films, cooking, dining out, reading, motorsports, gaming, and walking along the beach next to her house with her dog.

Read more posts by Liz Flynn

Related Articles

Stay ahead of the curve with our most recent guides and articles on , freshly curated by our diligent editorial team for your immediate perusal.
As featured on:

Wealth Insight!
Subscribe to our Exclusive Newsletter

Dive into the world of wealth and extravagance with Money Inc! Discover stock tips, businesses, luxury items, and travel experiences curated for the affluent observer.
linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram