Making M&A Magic: Managing the Human Factor When Companies Collide

CEOs assessing a potential merger or acquisition are typically laser-focused on the financial implications of the deal: “How could this opportunity lead to a stronger bottom line and better return for investors?” With that being the overwhelming focus, it’s no coincidence that 83% of mergers fail. Many leaders and transition drivers within companies never realize there’s more to a successful M&A process than just the financials.

Chief executives who neglect to perform due diligence on the unique challenges of combining different corporate cultures and unique groups of people risk having the planned transaction unwind, even when the financial benefit is clear.

Incorporating culture integration into your due diligence process can ensure that your business won’t experience a similar disappointment. Tellingly, 75% of executives cite “harmonizing culture and communicating with employees” as the most important factors for successful post-merger integration, and culture clashes have been responsible for some extremely high-profile failed mergers. Differences such as the assumed level of formality, consensus versus agile decision-making, and fears that the acquiring company won’t adequately care for or about the acquired company can all create internal friction that disrupts performance and productivity. A troubled post-merger company climate can lead to the departure of key executives. If your team is focused on internal scuffles instead of the competition, you risk losing valuable human capital as well as market share.

Mona Sabet, an entrepreneur, business executive, diversity advocate and seasoned attorney,  has shared her M&A experiences and insights with us to represent the challenges, missed opportunities, and imperative considerations for companies executing an acquisition.

“Individuals, leadership teams, and even organizations have energetic preferences, and when those energetic preferences are ignored, problems arise. Corporate development executives often see this play out when large companies acquire technology startups.  I use technology startups as an example partly because it’s the space we work in, but also because they represent a segment that has to move very quickly and innovate in order to be viewed as successful in their marketplace.

“I’ve been involved in acquisitions where we’ve paid a nice premium for the company. In each case, we identified key executives who we wanted to incent to stay with us post-acquisition.  Standard practice in M&A is to use monetary incentives and titles. We give them stock that vests over time hoping that they will stick around at least until the stock vests and, during that period, grow to want to stay with us. We give them impressive titles that they can put on their LinkedIn profiles! But, in all the cases that immediately come to mind, these key executives ended up leaving – either as soon as their stock vested, or in some cases, before that. So, if monetary and other extrinsic incentives don’t work, you have to start wondering about what does.

“It would have been helpful to have had the 5 Dynamics lens. If a company really incorporated the learnings from 5 Dynamics into its organizational development and structure, there would be a few differences in the M&A team integration experience.

  • “First, the acquiring company would already have an understanding of the overall work preferences of the team into which the acquisition would be integrated. That team would know if they ‘skew’ to a certain work style. They would also have already developed the skills to learn how to leverage the work preferences of people who are different from themselves.
  • “Second, I imagine that the M&A diligence process would include a 5 Dynamics assessment of the incoming team – or at least the key employees that the company has identified as a critical part of the value drivers of the deal.
  • “With an understanding of the energies of the incoming team, we would be better equipped to help the two teams integrate by making room for and leveraging each other’s strengths, rather than expecting the incoming team to conform to the ‘culture’ of the existing team.

“In the cases that I referred to earlier, the key executives didn’t get to a point where they felt a sense of belonging. Having gotten to know them, I look back and think that what we’d call the ‘culture’ of the team we pulled them into wasn’t appreciating the style they brought to the table.”

“Each of these executives were innovators, but they were very different.  One was highly analytical, while the other two were what we normally term as ‘visionaries.’  But the company, like all large companies, put a high premium on execution with short term wins. Quickly getting to cultural alignment and belonging can create more intrinsic motivators for the incoming team rather than just relying on extrinsic motivators like money and titles.  And it’s fairly well accepted that intrinsic motivators are significantly more successful in employee retention.”

-Mona Sabet, http://www.monasabet.com/

A high-functioning integration team helps avoid the possibility that one of the parties will back out and promotes efficiencies in the 1-2 year integration process that improve performance. Executives preparing for a merger or acquisition would do well to create a plan to support the happy and productive working relationships of individuals on the integration team. As every good CEO knows, the most effective teams are those where each member has different perspectives and strengths. One person might excel at building enthusiasm and support with key stakeholders, another at preparing detailed plans and schedules. One person may be exceptional at outside-the-box thinking, while another shines in deploying currently available resources and information to execute a plan.

Managing and aligning an integration team with different strengths requires planning; it takes effort and insight to help people with different styles learn to work well in collaboration together. Building an understanding of the different cultures and working styles at play can help to ensure a successful merger, minimizing delays and identifying opportunities to effectively accelerate the process. Given the significant risks involved in culture integration, the frustrations that employees experience with the process, and the higher probability of talent loss during a merger or acquisition, selecting an effective solution is paramount. The next time you are involved with an M&A activity, after you have considered the financials and the product or service fit, be sure to also consider how you can successfully and smoothly blend the two cultures.


Add Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Afya Limited
20 Things You Didn’t Know About Afya Limited
Bruce Kovner
20 Things You Didn’t Know About Bruce Kovner
Zsolt Felcsuti
The 10 Richest People in Hungary
Aprea
20 Things You Didn’t Know About Aprea Therapeutics
Portfolio
The Top 10 Mutual Funds by 10 Year Performance
Navy Federal Credit Card
The 10 Best Credit Cards for Military Members
cryptocurrency
The 10 Most Valuable Cryptocurrencies in the World
The 10 Best Credit Cards for Small Businesses
solar panels
The Five Best Solar Panel Companies Based on Efficiency
airpods
Why Are AirPods So Expensive? Here’s The Answer
Computer Virus
The 10 Worst Computer Viruses of All-Time
printer ink
Why is Printer Ink So Expensive? Here’s the Answer
Florida U.S. 1
The 20 Worst Roads in America in 2019
The Top 10 Golf Courses in Orlando, Florida
Why The Private Suite at LAX is the Ultimate Airport Experience
THE PHOENICIAN GOLF CLUB
The Top 10 Golf Courses in Scottsdale, Arizona
The Porsche 911 Carrera RS
10 of the Best Porsche Carrera Models of All Time
Ferrari Testarossa
10 Best Ferrari Testarossa Models of All-Time
1982 Porsche 944
The Five Best Porsche 944 Models of All-Time
Ferrari Portofino
10 Things You’ll Love About the Ferrari Portofino
A Closer Look at the Hublot Bigger Bang
IWC Big Pilot's Watch Constant-Force Tourbillon Edition Le Petit Prince
A Closer Look at the IWC Big Pilot’s Watch Constant-Force Tourbillon Edition Le Petit Prince
A Closer Look at the Jaeger-LeCoultre Master Ultra Thin Tourbillon
Time Traveling: The Hublot Classic Fusion Zirconium