The 10 Best Places To Get Apple Pie in NYC

New York City

New York City is called The Big Apple for good reason. The city is home to some of the best bakeries in the world. It’s known for its scrumptious apple pie. If you get a hankering for apple pie when visiting, we have a list of the ten best places to go for the best apple pie in NYC.

10. Little Pie Company

424 W 43rd St, New York

The Little Pie Company is not a fancy bakery. It’s a down-to-earth establishment that doesn’t need any frills to produce some of the best kinds of apple pie in the world. The bakery specializes in making a variety of different types of apple pie using the best ingredients. They make every pie from scratch. You have your choice of Old-fashioned apple pie, Sour cream apple walnut pie, Pear apple crumb pie in season, or Sugarless apple pie. Each kind is available in a choice of three sizes. They’re great for single servings or the whole family. The establishment also makes muffins and cookies.

9. Petee’s Pie Company

61 Delancey St, New York

When you’re on the East Side of the city, Petee’s Pie Company is open daily from 11 am to 11 pm to meet all your dessert needs. The bakery offers a convenient online ordering system to get your apple pie and more. They’re happy to fill orders the same day or at another time in the future. Petee’s ships orders anywhere in the world. New York Magazine announced that Petee’s sells the “absolute best pie in New York.” The award-winning bakery is family-run and is in its second generation of gourmet bakers. The company sells small pies, large pies singles, or boxed sets.

8. Two Little Red Hens

1652 2nd Ave, New York

Two Little Red Hens is a premier bakery in New York City that offers a little bit of everything gourmet you can find in a bakery. Their classic apple pie is a double-crust pie made with apples and spice. They’re available by the slice to serve one person, or a 10-inch pie that serves 8. The bakery also offers an apple crumb pie, a Fall Medley pie with apples, other fruits, and berries, and an apple cranberry version.

7. Sweet Chef

122 Hamilton Pl, New York

The Sweet chef is a quaint storefront bakeshop with artisanal southern-style pies. The bakery specializes in pies, cakes, and other desserts. It’s especially well-known for its apple crumb pie. Sweet Chef is a small establishment, but it has big reviews from the locals who love apple pie. You can check out the glowing reviews. It’s enough to make you want to give them a try.

6. Pie Corps

77 Driggs Ave, Brooklyn

Pie Corps is known for its killer Apple Crumble Pie. Sweet Chef bakery also has a vegan version, so you can say there is something for everyone. They also offer a classic apple pie. Pie Corps is one of the most popular bakeries on Driggs Avenue with its sweet and savory pies. You can eat an entire dinner and have your dessert. The pastry chefs only use locally sourced ingredients in their scratch-made pies. If you’re interested in learning how to make your apple pie, they also offer classes.

5. Allen’s Pie LLC

Allen’s Pie is not a bakery you drive to for pickup. They deliver it directly to you. They make one of the best apple pies in New York City. Each pie is homemade from scratch. The pastry chef procures Granny Smith apples and only true Ceylon cinnamon, nutmeg, flour, sugar, and other premium ingredients in each apple pie. The bakery delivers to New York City, Yonkers, Western Long Island, Westchester, and will schedule other delivery options for customers in the state of New York.

4. Four and Twenty Blackbirds

439 3rd Ave, Brooklyn

Four and Twenty Blackbirds is one of the best bakeries in the state of New York. The establishment is known for its apple pie. Many customers leave glowing reviews and claim that the apple pie is the best in the city. The bakery’s specialty is a salted caramel apple pie that combines sweet and salty together in a tempting dessert that will make your mouth water and leave you wanting more. Their pies are addictive. Four and Twenty Blackbirds offers dozens of gourmet pie options for those who demand nothing but the best.

3. Fancy Pies

1580 Park Ave, New York

Fancy Pies is a Park Avenue bakery that specializes in making apple pie with a twist. Bap’s Sour Cream Apple Walnut is a bougie apple pie featuring toasted walnuts, a variety of apple varieties, and a tangy sour cream. If you prefer to keep it traditional, their Nana’s Alabama apple pie features a double crust with mixed apple varieties and light spices and sweetener.

2. Billy’s Bakery

184 9th Ave, New York

Billy’s Bakery is another premier locale to find the best apple pie in the country. It’s a popular bakery because the ingredients are fresh and the pies are made from scratch. The bakery is in a 1940s style venue, offering pies, cheesecakes, cupcakes, cakes, and more.

1. Miss American Pie

86 5th Avenue Brooklyn

Miss American Pie serves one of the best apple pies in New York. The bakery specializes in baking pies of all kinds from chicken pot pie for dinner to its tasty apple and other pies, cookies, cakes, and more. Customers love the retro theme of the pie shop. It offers gluten-free and vegan options along with coffee and other drinks.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.