The Top 20 Steakhouses in New York City

Peter Luger Steak

There are many cities out there that contain some of the best restaurants and food on the planet, and then there’s New York. As far as most steak lovers should be concerned, New York City has the best food in the world. While I don’t live in New York City anymore, I’ve had my fair share of fantastic steak.  And growing up on Long Island, I’ve traveled to NYC on more than one occasion for the fantastic steakhouses all over the place. There aren’t many places in the world where you have what feels like unlimited steak options.  Now, there are many incredible steakhouses in New York, but only a few stand out above the rest. So we are going to look at the top 20 best steakhouses that New York City has to offer. So as not to get into too many arguments, there is no order to this list.  It’s just a list where these steakhouses belong.  Plain and simple.

1. St. Anselm – 335 Metropolitan Avenue

St. Anselm NYC

Out in Brooklyn is St. Anselm, and with fierce competition from another name on out list, the folks over at St. Anselm strive to be the best. Located in Williamsburg, St. Anselm is a no-fuss, straight-to-the-point steakhouse. The steaks are good, the sides are large, and the prices are very reasonable.

2. The Palm Restaurant – 837 Second Avenue (and Palm Too)

Originally established in 1926 by Pio Bozzi and John Ganzi, The Palm Restaurant is one of the city’s standout steakhouses. The restaurant is still family-owned today, and it is a unique location that serves not only steakhouse classics, but Italian food as well. So in addition to filets, rib-eye steaks, and crab cakes, you can also get dishes like veal marsala or chicken parmigiana.

3. Sparks – 210 E 46th St

Sparks

According to Zagat – A “quintessential” “NY classic”, this 1966-vintage Midtown “temple of beef” “still shines” with “huge” cuts of “mouthwatering” meats and an “exhaustive” wine list administered by an “experienced” team; “manly” – bordering on “stodgy” – surrounds and “power-lunch” prices are all part of its “old-world charm.”

4. Keen’s Steakhouse – 71 West 36 Street

Keens Steakhouse Bar

Keen’s Steakhouse is a New York staple and is certainly a legendary location. Keen’s has been serving guests with some of the best meals in the city since it first opened its doors in 1885. Since it’s been around that long, you just know it has to be great. It’s a classic steakhouse complete with dim lights, walls adorned with thousands of tobacco pipes, a terrific whiskey selection, and obviously some pretty incredible steaks.

5. Ben and Jack’s – 255 5th Avenue

Ben and Jacks

There are two Ben and Jack’s Steakhouse located in the city, however the one on 44th Street is currently under renovation. Founded and owned by brothers Ben and Jack Sinanaj, and with the help from some other family members, Ben and Jack’s Steakhouse is another great place to eat. The Sinanaj brothers had been working in New York kitchens since they were young boys, and eventually opened up their first steakhouse in 2005. Ever since, it’s become very popular and is certainly a great place to eat.

6. Porter House New York – 10 Columbus Circle

The Porter House

Located in the Time Warner Center, Porter House New York is another leading steakhouse within the city. Chef Michael Lomonaco serves up some pretty great steaks at a very reasonable price (at least, by New York terms). They have a large menu and with over 500 different types of wine, it’s always an easy pick.

7. American Cut – 363 Greenwich Street

Located in TriBeCa, American Cut is another excellent steakhouse that you should visit the next time you’re in the city (or if you live there and haven’t checked it out yet). Created by Iron Chef Marc Forgione, American Cut is a modern joint that’s actually fairly large for the city since there are 180 seats in total here. Menus at steakhouses are usually fairly similar, but at American Cut you can also enjoy dishes like veal, lamb, and chicken so if you’re not in the mood for steak, they have other offerings.

8. Nick & Stef’s Steakhouse – 9 Pennsylvania Plaza

Constantly rated as one of the best steakhouses in the city, Nick & Stef’s is a high-class, quality steakhouse that serves up some choice meats. This is a restaurant where the traditional steakhouse meets fine dining, and you’ll probably want to wear a jacket to this one. But it’s worth getting dressed up for, as their food is pretty spectacular.

9. Christos Steakhouse – 4108 23rd Avenue

While Christos is a bit out of the way from downtown since it’s out in Queens, it’s another great steakhouse that’s worth eating at. It used to be a Greek restaurant but has since been converted into a premium steak joint that has a lot of people talking. It feels like an old-fashioned chop shop with some Greek elements that make it certainly very New York. The menu is expansive and large, and they have something for everyone.

10. Strip House – 13 East 12th Street

Strip House has actually three different locations in the city, but we are going to look at the one that’s downtown. It gives off the vibe of a classic steakhouse mixed with modern elements, so it’s just perfect. As the name implies, they are known for their strip steak here, yet obviously everything is great. They serve the classics, some seafood, and a few dishes that are more “progressive”.

11. The Old Homestead Steakhouse – 56 Nineth Avenue

For more than one hundred years, The Old Homestead Steakhouse has been offering diners some of the finest steaks in the entire world, and it is consistently praised as one of the top locations in New York. Lead by executive chef Oscar Martinez, The Old Homestead has a diverse menu and they serve lunch as well (many steakhouse only do dinners). Take your pick from 40 day aged rib steak and large filet minions, or enjoy a kobe burger or Chilean seabags, The Old Homestead has you covered.

12. Uncle Jack’s Steakhouse – 440 Ninth Avenue

Like Strip House, Uncle Jack’s has three different locations and all are absolutely excellent. This is an iconic and well-known steakhouse in New York, and many consider their steaks to be the absolute best. Despite only opening up in 1996, Uncle Jack’s quickly became one of the top steakhouses in the entire city.

13. Quality Meats – 57 West 58th Street

Founded by Michael Stillman who was the son of Alan Stillman, one of the Smith & Wollensky founders, Quality Meats is another standout steakhouse in New York City. The ambiance and interior are certainly non-traditional and feel more artistic that other steakhouses (a positive in my book), yet they have all the classic favorites that you’d expect.

14. Minetta Tavern – 113 Macdougal Street

Recently resorted and rebranded, the Minetta Tavern is now a hot spot for great steaks. From New York strip steaks and filets to dry aged burgers, there’s a lot to choose from over at the Minetta Tavern. The bartenders here are also pretty well known and they serve up some great cocktails.

15. Gallaghers Steakhouse – 228 West 52nd Street

Perfectly situated a quick walk away from Broadway and Times Square, Gallaghers is extremely inviting. From the window outside and when you walk in, you’ll see their meat locker with all of their cuts aging to perfection. A true artists displays their work, and that’s what their steaks are. From prime rib to Maine lobster, Gallaghers has it all and they’ve got the history to prove it.

16. Costata – 206 Spring Street

Costata is an upscale steakhouse that has an Italian twist. There menu is more diverse that other steakhouses in the city. In addition to offering classics like rib eye and filet mignon, you can also get things like spaghetti and risotto so you’re not just confided to traditional steakhouse offerings.

17. Smith & Wollensky – 797 3rd Avenue

Tried and trusted, the Smith & Wollensky brand is a trusted name within the steakhouse industry, and their New York location is still not only one of the best steakhouses in the city, but the country as well. It’s an upscale restaurant that serve all the classics, and they even deliver as well. Having lunch or dinner here is never a mistake.

18. Wolfgang’s Steakhouse – 4 Park Avenue

There are five different Wolfgang’s Steakhouse locations in the city, and all serve extraordinary dishes. The restaurants were founded by Wolfgang Zwiener who used to be the head waiter at Peter Luger, but after 40-years there, he wanted to create his own restaurant. The location on Park Avenue was the first when it opened in 2005, and as you can see, business has been good considering how much they have expanded not only in New York, but the world over as well.

19. M. Wells Steakhouse – 43-15 Crescent Street

You would not expect to find an incredible steakhouse located in an old car garage in Queens, but that’s exactly what M. Wells is. Okay, it doesn’t look like a car garage at all obviously, but it’s still cool to mention. This is a non-traditional steakhouse that, while does have the classics, they also serve many avant-garde dishes. The atmosphere is extremely unique as a black and white film is usually playing on a projector. When you want to break away from boring and traditional steakhouses, but want one that still delivers, M. Wells is the place to go.

20. Peter Luger – 178 Broadway

Some will argue that Pete Luger is now all but a tourist trap (aka hipsters in Brooklyn), while many will tell you it’s the best steakhouse in the world. Regardless, Peter Luger has been in business since 1887 and has so many awards over the years. It’s easily the most famous steakhouse in the city and a favorite among many. When a new steakhouse opens up anywhere in the country, they look to see how they compare to this iconic location. It’s still definitely the best-of-the-best, just bring cash with you because they still don’t take credit cards.  I personally prefer the one in Long Island but that’s probably because it’s just nicer on the inside.

Honorable Mention:

  • The Capital Grille
  • Rothman’s
  • Morton’s
  • Del Frisco’s


Add Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

How Erin Burnett Achieved a Net Worth of $13 Million
Richard Adam Norwitt
10 Things You Didn’t Know About Amphenol CEO Richard Adam Norwitt
Peter Weedfald and Steve Forbes
Change, Focus, Speed
Harley Logo
The Importance of a Unique Creative Logo Design for Your Company
chase sapphire reserve card
Whatever Happened to The Chase Sapphire Reserve Price Protection Plan?
General Mills
Why General Mills is a Solid Dividend Stock for the Next 20 Years
The Top 10 Chase Sapphire Reserve Card Airport Lounges
Enbdrige
Why Enbridge (ENB) is a Great Dividend Stock for Retirees
Biosphere 2
Closed Ecological Systems: Can They Save the Future?
brain computer interface
How Close is Brain-Computer Interface To Being a Reality?
agricultural robots
What Are Agricultural Robots and How Will They Change the Future?
New Orleans Arcology
What is an Arcology and How Close are We To Having One?
New York Earth Room
10 Reasons to Visit the New York Earth Room
High Line
10 Reasons You Should Walk the NYC High Line
The Porter House
Why Porter House New York is One of the Best NYC Steakhouses
10 Reasons to Stay at the Ritz-Carlton Dorado Beach
1964 Ferrari 250 LM Rear
Is the 1964 Ferrari 250 LM Really Worth $18.26 Million?
1966 Shelby GT350
The 20 Greatest Muscle Cars of All-Time
1956 Cadillac Series 62 Eldorado Seville Coupe
The 20 Best Cadillac Eldorado Models of All Time
Veneno Showroom
The Lamborghini Veneno Roadster: A Rare and Limited Edition
Patek Philippe Pink Gold Pocket Watch 1894
A Closer Look at the $2.29 Million Patek Philippe Pink Gold Pocket Watch 1894
Patek Philippe Perpetual Calendar Chronograph Wristwatch in Pink Gold
A Closer Look at the $2.28 Million Patek Philippe Perpetual Calendar Chronograph Wristwatch in Pink Gold
20 Things That You Didn’t Know About Breitling Watches
2019 Breitling
The 10 Best Breitling Watches of 2019